Describes experimental methods used for NGS quality assessment
p. 3
Presents results and discussion of quality assessment experiments
Specp. 4
Compares sizing and quantification approaches with data tables
Overviewp. 5
Summarizes key findings and conclusions of the assessment
p. 2table, 10 rows
p. 4table, 4 rows
Table 1. Agilent automated electrophoresis instruments and assay specifications.
Assay Specifications
Bioanalyzer High Sensitivity DNA
Fragment Analyzer High Sensitivity NGS
Fragment Analyzer High Sensitivity Small Fragment
TapeStation High Sensitivity D1000
Sizing Range
50 - 7,000 bp
100 - 6,000 bp
50 - 1,500 bp
35 - 1,000 bp
Typical Resolution
50 - 600 bp: 10%
100 - 1,000 bp: ≤5% 2
50 -900 bp: ≤5% 2
35 - 300 bp: 15%
600 - 7,000 bp: 20%
1,000 - 6,000 bp: ≤10% 2
900 - 1,500 bp: ≤10% 2
300 - 1,000 bp: 10%
Sizing Precision
5 %CV 1
2 %CV 1
2 %CV 1,3
5 %CV 1
Sizing Accuracy (%error)
±10% 1
±5% 1
±5% 1,3
±10% 1,4
Quantitative Precision
50 - 2,000 bp: 15 %CV 1
15 %CV 1
15 %CV 1
15 %CV 1
2,000 -7,000 bp: 10 %CV 1
Quantitative Accuracy (%error)
±20% 1
±25% 1
±25% 1
±20% 1
Quantitative Range
Fragment 5 - 500 pg/µL
Fragment 5 - 500 pg/µL 1,3
Fragment 5 - 500 pg/µL 1,3
10 - 1,000 pg/µL
Smear 100 - 10,000 pg/µL
Smear 50 - 5,000 pg/µL 3
Smear 100 - 5,000 pg/µL 3
1 Determined using ladder as sample; 2 Determined using short array; 3 Determined using DNA samples in 1X TE buffer; 4 Sizing accuracy for analysis with electronic ladder: ±20%
Table 1
Instrument and Kit
Average Size (bp) Library 1
Average Size (bp) Library 2
%CV Library 1
%CV Library 2
Bioanalyzer High Sensitivity DNA
431
470
0.35
0.43
Fragment Analyzer High Sensitivity NGS
419
448
0.96
0.22
Fragment Analyzer High Sensitivity Small Fragment
429
457
0.54
0.25
TapeStation High Sensitivity D1000
423
446
1.54
0.22
Figure 2. Sizing comparison. The average size of two NGS libraries reported by the Agilent Bioanalyzer, Agilent Fragment Analyzer, and Agilent TapeStation systems. Error bars represent standard deviation. n = 3 replicates per instrument.
Engineering Facts
11 facts · every claim linked to a page
Selection
Choose the assay kit so its sizing range covers the expected NGS smear, since the kits differ in sizing range and resolution.
Kit sizing range must match the sample smear to obtain valid sizing and quantification.
Source
“The DNA analysis kits chosen for analysis of the NGS libraries in this paper have similar specifications (Table 1), with a sizing range well-suited for the NGS smear, allowing for comparison between the instruments.”
Selection
The Bioanalyzer High Sensitivity DNA kit covers 50-7,000 bp, wider than the other three kits listed.
Defines whether a kit can size fragments outside the 200-1,000 bp smear window.
Source
“Sizing Range 50 - 7,000 bp”
Selection
The TapeStation High Sensitivity D1000 kit only sizes up to 1,000 bp, so larger fragments fall outside its range.
Prevents selecting this kit for libraries with fragments above 1,000 bp.
Source
“35 - 1,000 bp”
Performance
Quantitative accuracy differs by platform: Bioanalyzer and TapeStation are ±20% error while Fragment Analyzer kits are ±25%.
Sets the expected concentration error budget when comparing platforms.
Source
“±20% 1 ±25% 1 ±25% 1 ±20% 1”
Operation
The quantitative range depends on whether fragments or smears are measured, with smear ranges differing per kit.
Sample concentration must fall inside the applicable fragment or smear range for reliable quantification.
Use the smear/region function to quantify only the portion of sample inside the set size window and to get its average size.
Correct region setup is required to get meaningful library concentration and size values.
Source
“The smear analysis functions allow the user to determine the quantification of only the portion of sample that lies within the smear range, as well as the average size of the sample within the range.”
Performance
Sizing precision across all instruments was better than 1.6 %CV in triplicate measurements.
Confirms sizing repeatability is adequate for library QC decisions.
Source
“The sizing across each instrument showed excellent precision, with each system displaying less than 1.6 %CV (Figure 2B).”
Performance
Bioanalyzer and Fragment Analyzer read slightly lower concentration than TapeStation, so cross-platform values are not identical.
Explains systematic offsets when transferring concentration values between platforms.
Source
“the Bioanalyzer and Fragment Analyzer consistently displayed a slightly lower value than the TapeStation (Figure 3).”
Performance
Measured quantification precision stayed under 15% CV and error versus Qubit stayed under 18%.
Gives realistic tolerance for concentration results versus a fluorometric reference.
Source
“The %CV for each library was less than 15% within each system, and the %error was below 18%.”
Selection
Because platform performance is equivalent, selection can be driven by throughput or speed needs.
Justifies choosing a platform on operational criteria rather than analytical differences.
Source
“researchers can have confidence in selecting any of the systems based on factors important to their laboratory’s needs, such as sample throughput or speed.”
Conformité
The instruments are for research use only and not for diagnostic procedures.
Restricts deployment to research settings, not clinical diagnostics.
Source
“For Research Use Only. Not for use in diagnostic procedures.”